Wayfarer – Riders of the Setting Sun Review

I try not to regret things like ratings and list placements. As reviewers, we’re limited by an element of timeliness when we write our pieces, so it’s only natural that our feelings change over time. But one regret I do have is this: American Gothic was significantly stronger than my seventh-favorite album of 2023, I just didn’t know it yet. Wayfarer’s blend of Wild West-flavored black metal was mighty, and it’s become a frequent listen since the start of 2024. My colleagues seem to agree: American Gothic was the highest-rated aggregated release from its year. Now, the U.S.-based band is back with their sixth full-length release since 2011. How do they follow up such an epic release? By doing something unexpected, of course: backtrack on the black metal completely, focus almost solely on the cool Americana, and let the music do all the talking for you. It’s a bold move, but then, no one remembers the timid cowboys (or at least I don’t).

Riders of the Setting Sun has the feel of an Americana album written by a black metal band. That foundation of country, rock, and gospel, adorned with lyrics and themes inspired by United States history, film, and literature, is darkened by Wayfarer’s grim atmosphere, with healthy doses of cynical lyrics, cinematic instrumentation, and confident performances. American Gothic this is not, but the melodic gothic country sound is familiar anyway, in the haunting chorus of “The Dusklands,” the gospel intoning of “Fell Spur,” and the sardonic darkness in “Grey Country.” Wayfarer incorporate elements of metal here and there: a fantastic and heartfelt guitar solo from Joe Strong-Truscelli in “Hollow Hearts on the Trail to Eden,” Isaac Faulk’s drumming throughout, and the fact that both Shane McCarthy and Jamie Hansen sing as if the apocalypse already happened. But Riders of the Setting Sun still trends closer to country than metal, and closer to gothic than black. But boy, do they make it work.

In part, that’s because Wayfarer do atmosphere exceptionally well, and with the black metal guitars pulled back, atmosphere reigns supreme on Riders of the Setting Sun. McCarthy’s singing and Faulk’s keys do a lot of the heavy lifting in that regard. Opener “The Dusklands” showcases the approach: a gothic-country acoustic base sets the stage, and the singing brings in the melodies. Electric guitars, keys, and bass distort the air, bringing a sense of weight to the song that brings everything together. Of course there are no screams this time ’round, but guest vocal spots from David Eugene Edwards (“Perdition’s Crossing”), Kelly Schilling (“Casey’s Lasy Ride”), Midwife (“Prairies of Babylon”), and Munly J. Munly (“Grey Country”) liven up half of the tracks, marking one of the most diverse listens Wayfarer have put out in some time—to my ears, anyway.

As is often the case when metal bands write acoustic albums, you can’t help but miss that sense of power behind the well-written melodies. Of course, Wayfarer have not gone nearly fully acoustic on Riders of the Setting Sun, but it’s still interesting to note that my favorite song is “Fell Spur” because the lead and backing vocals are so compelling and so Wayfarer; it builds with a quiet intensity and would be right at home on American Gothic despite being the most country-sounding song here. I could argue that songs focusing less on that intensity, like “Black Roses & Early Graves,” wind up feeling a bit forgettable, but it’s only because they’re not so engaging—they’re still written well and thrive in the gloomy West Wayfarer present. Similarly, “Casey’s Last Ride” builds a super-atmospheric chorus around Schilling’s beautiful singing, but it doesn’t, to my ears, fit the Western feel of the rest of the album, or indeed the song itself. These moments are few and far between, but to a brain primed for metal, they break the immersion a bit—but perhaps more than they should.

Fortunately, the intensely beautiful atmosphere Wayfarer have built with Riders of the Setting Sun make it such an easy album to get lost in, right up to the gorgeous, ghostly climax of “Hollow Hearts on the Trail to Eden.” Riders of the Setting Sun feels like an important album for Wayfarer, one that follows an exceptional metal album with a strong thematic one. Western, black metal, or both, it seems Wayfarer can do it all, and I love getting to be here for the ride.


Rating: 3.5/5.0
DR: N/A | Format Reviewed: Stream
Label: Vesperian
Websites: wayfarercolorado.bandcamp.com | facebook.com/wayfarercolorado
Releases Worldwide: November 20th, 2026

The post Wayfarer – Riders of the Setting Sun Review appeared first on Angry Metal Guy.