Kamelot should need no introduction, but this is an article, so they get one anyway. The US-based group have dominated at a crossroads between power, progressive, and symphonic metal for much of the thirty-one years since their debut. I can personally credit Kamelot with breaking me out of my Nightwish-shaped early impression of metal, and I still love their approach to the style; they’ve created their own sound, and they do it well. Over their last few albums, however, Kamelot have sounded a little too much like themselves, with recent releases sounding very much like one another. Whether or not that’s a good thing is up to the individual, but for this reviewer, the question isn’t whether Dark Asylum, their fourteenth full-length, will be good, but whether it will feel new, fresh, or exciting.
Dark Asylum is a Kamelot record, no doubt about it. Seasoned as they are, it’s hard for Kamelot to miss, and their signature sound—that dark, polished power metal augmented by bombastic orchestration and ear-worm choruses—is on full display here. Even the structure of Dark Asylum is typical of Kamelot: opener “Sanctorium” is an overly dramatic intro that probably doesn’t need to be there, and “Ashen World” is mighty, galloping symphonic power metal led by melodic guitar leads from Youngblood and a riveting vocal performance from Karevik that recalls “Veil of Elysium,” though it has nothing on the phenomenal chorus of the title track that follows. It’s a very Kamelot way to open an album: huge choruses of the Haven variety supported by melodic leads that echo Ghost Opera. Throughout, Oliver Palotai’s keys build their own melodies, support the catchy choruses, and add ambience as songs demand. It’s a familiar formula to anyone who’s listened to Kamelot in the last decade, with the same highs and lows as you’re used to.
In fact, it’s so typical of Kamelot’s last decade that I could probably just quote previous reviews to tell you about it. As with The Shadow Theory, Youngblood’s rhythm guitars are increasingly pushed to the background. This weakens otherwise anthemic songs like “One Last Masquerade,” which features Tobias Sammet and subsequently sounds more like a bonus track from Avantasia’s Ghostlights than Kamelot. Also, as with The Shadow Theory, Kamelot’s production of harsh vocals makes them feel superficial; in this case, it’s primarily “Sanctuary” that just kind of has them, though not for lack of effort by Ignacia Fernández (Decessus). Of course, Kamelot still take themselves very seriously, so much so that there’s a 40-second track for Latin singing that may be important for the story, but feels completely out of place as an actual track. Finally, while Karevik’s silky vocals are a terrific match for Kamelot’s music and vision, he still seems to be struggling a little to deliver on high notes, particularly in the chorus of “Godlike Alchemy.”
So it seems Dark Asylum is a familiar story: when Kamelot succeed, they really succeed, and if they could just do it for fifteen straight tracks, their latest could be their best. Although the muted rhythm guitars hold back Dark Asylum as a whole, it has some great highs: “Cassandra’s Disease,” “Ashen World,” “One Last Masquerade,” the title track. But it also has “Beneath the Moon (Tunglið),” a Nordic ballad that feels like it’s on the wrong album1, and “Enigma (Think of Me),” a forgettable power ballad that misses the mark on both sides of that moniker. Dark Asylum works best when Kamelot do what they do best: inspired, memorable guitar leads and soaring choruses. Songs that reach for this but don’t quite land include “Kaleidoscope” and “The Puppet King,” both of which are fine, but leave little impact. Kamelot’s passion for their sound is evident, but consistency in songwriting is something they have, to my ears, struggled with in recent years, and Dark Asylum continues that trend.
Of course, even when Kamelot does miss, they’re still Kamelot, so Dark Asylum has some truly great songs on it. It’s not fresh, though; it’s not exciting. I truly admire Kamelot for the passion they still have for what they do. I was, however, hoping for more than the same album; it now feels like they’ve done thrice before.
Rating: 2.5/5.0
DR: N/A | Format Reviewed: Stream
Label: Napalm Records
Websites: kamelot.bandcamp.com | kamelot.com | facebook.com/kamelotofficial
Releases Worldwide: August 28th, 2026
The post Kamelot – Dark Asylum Review appeared first on Angry Metal Guy.
